"Zeal for your house will consume me" (Ps 69:9)

Thoughts of a parish priest…

Pope Francis and the Holy Mass


Pope Francis spoke recently about something that is very dear to me, namely, the importance of the Holy Mass as a mysterious and sacred encounter with the living God and more than just the gathering of Catholics to pray together.

He explained that Holy Mass is not just a “social act” or a “prayer gathering,” but the place where “the presence of the Lord is real, truly real.”

“When we celebrate the Mass, we don’t accomplish a representation of the Last Supper,” the pope said, explaining that, “IT IS the Last Supper itself.”


His comments made me think of an encounter I had a few years ago.  Just after I had finished celebrating the Holy Mass, I was asked by a member of the congregation, “Father, I noticed that when you say the Mass, you really don’t seem to be looking at us a whole lot. Why is that?” My initial reaction and response was “Well, when I celebrate the Mass, I am speaking to our Lord and not with the congregation.”

In response to this very good question, I attempted to clarify this common misconception that the Mass is primarily a dialogue between the priest and the congregation, or this sort of social gathering that the pope was referring to.

With the exception of just a few dialogical parts, i.e., “the Lord be with you …  lift up your hearts …” the Mass is not a dialogue between the priest and the congregation as if it were simply a performance reenacting the Last Supper. The Mass is a dialogue between us and Almighty God, a dialogue in which the priest is leading, but one in which everyone is (or should be) participating. 


Maybe we have never thought of it in these terms. Maybe we were formed in a way of thinking that leads us to believe that Mass is essentially about “us,” about what “we” get out of it, about how it makes “me” feel.  But if we listen closely to the prayers that are said during the Mass it becomes abundantly clear that we are speaking above all to God the Father. 

Msgr. Guido Marini, pontifical master of Liturgical Ceremonies, spoke of this very topic, explaining that, “theologically speaking, the holy Mass, as a matter of fact, is always addressed to God through Christ our Lord, and it would be a grievous error to imagine that the principal orientation of the sacrificial action is the community.”

Pope Francis has in essence invited us to plunge into the unfathomable and sacred mystery of the Mass! To do so, it is crucial that we first understand the very nature of the liturgy and to whom it is being directed. If we are truly to encounter our Lord in the breaking of the bread as did the disciples on the road to Emmaus, our hearts and minds must be open to and formed by the liturgical actions and prayers themselves. The Mass is ultimately about the worship and adoration of God, not about any emotional response it may invoke.


As a former high school chaplain, I often heard from the students, “I don’t get anything out of the Mass” or “It is so hard to pay attention or stay focused.” I don’t believe for a minute that this response is limited to teen-agers, even though they may express it in a more straightforward manner. The same is true, however, of any event or activity that we attend. If we are unfamiliar with what is happening or to the real beauty in how it is executed, then, certainly, we will not appreciate or be able to enter into it. 

For example, I remember the first professional soccer game that I went to in Italy. I knew the basic point of the game was to kick the ball into the opponents’ net and I knew that you couldn’t use your hands, but that was the extent of my awareness of the game. I didn’t understand strategy or the concept of being off-sides or how the individual players functioned together as a team. There was an initial excitement about being in a huge stadium with thousands of screaming Romans, but after that initial excitement faded away, I was quite bored. 

I imagine that this feeling is similar to that of those who “get nothing out of the Mass” or find it “boring.” When one is unfamiliar with the beauty and the sacredness of such an encounter with God, then that response is almost natural. The question that I continually asked myself as a high school chaplain, trying to foster in the students an appreciation and love for the Mass, was “How do we reclaim the sense of wonder and awe of the Mass that the generations of Catholics before us experienced?” How do we restore the sense of the sacred?


Over and over again, I came to the same two-fold conclusion. On the part of ministers of the Church, first we must persistently provide and embrace an ongoing catechesis for Catholics of all ages and states of life. How can we live out our faith and celebrate it liturgically if we are unaware of what we truly believe as Catholics? 

The second thing that is necessary is to provide reverent and solemn celebrations of the Mass allowing its natural beauty to lead us into contact with the presence of God. There is nothing I or any other priest can do to make the Mass more beautiful or engaging or interesting than it already is on its merits. At each Mass Jesus Christ becomes truly present — there is nothing more awesome than that.

These are the things the Church provides. Each of us, however, has the responsibility actively to seek to grow in our faith and not just go about things as passive members of the Church. If we are to “get more” out of the Mass, we ought first to strive to understand the Mass by reflecting upon how we approach Mass in the first place. We need to ask the question, “Is this about worshiping and praising God?” or “Is it about me and how it makes me feel?”


2 thoughts on “Pope Francis and the Holy Mass

  1. Great article, Fr Mello! Important analysis. I just blogged about the internal disposition we need to bring to the Mass. http://fathersouza.com/2014/02/11/the-internal-dimension-of-following-jesus/

  2. I came across this article and read it with great interest. I especially appreciate your points on the Mass as the Sacrifice of Christ, the Paschal Mystery made present to us on the altar. However, there were a couple of points that I think are worthwhile to add to the discussion.

    First, you say that Mass is not only a social event – that is true, as you described. I do think, however, that in reaction to some of the abuses that have occurred in the Mass over the last 50 years, there is a tendency to “throw the baby out with the bathwater” and forget the reforms and teachings on the liturgy that the Second Vatican Council proclaimed in Sacrosanctum Concilium. The council reiterated the Sacrificial character of the Mass

    At the Last Supper, on the night when He was betrayed, our Savior instituted the eucharistic sacrifice of His Body and Blood. He did this in order to perpetuate the sacrifice of the Cross throughout the centuries until He should come again, and so to entrust to His beloved spouse, the Church, a memorial of His death and resurrection: a sacrament of love, a sign of unity, a bond of charity, a paschal banquet in which Christ is eaten, the mind is filled with grace, and a pledge of future glory is given to us.

    Sacrosanctum Concilium #36

    At the same time, though, it also speaks heavily on the Mass’s communal character:

    And therefore the liturgical life of the parish and its relationship to the bishop must be fostered theoretically and practically among the faithful and clergy; efforts also must be made to encourage a sense of community within the parish, above all in the common celebration of the Sunday Mass.

    Sacrosanctum Concilium #42

    The Mass has many characteristics. It is first and foremost an offering of the Sacrifice of Christ, but it is also an opportunity to be nourished by God’s word, to be fed Christ’s Body and Blood, really and truly present in the Eucharist, from the table of the Lord. Indeed, the Liturgy of the Word itself is primarily directed from the ministers (lectors and deacon and/or priest) to the gathered assembly, while much of the Liturgy of the Eucharist is directed to the Father. So I think it is not fully correct to say “With the exception of just a few dialogical parts, i.e., “the Lord be with you … lift up your hearts …” the Mass is not a dialogue between the priest and the congregation”.

    Finally, I think your statement “How do we reclaim the sense of wonder and awe of the Mass that the generations of Catholics before us experienced?” presents a bit of liturgical nostalgia that doesn’t represent the historical reality of the history of the Mass. By the close of the 19th century, the Mass had become simply an event to be attended and to pray at, privately. It was something that the Priest did, that you had to go to, and rarely receive communion, but was often done poorly and in silence. The grand “high Masses” with Palestrina were virtually unknown except at the Cathedral level, and Gregorian Chant was a lost art. It was this situation that inspired the 20th century liturgical movement to restore the Mass to its original prominence in the life of Catholics. Through the reforms of Pope Saint Pius X, Pope Pius XII, and Pope John XXXIII, along with liturgical scholars such as Fr. Josef Jungmann and the Monks at Solesmes, much of what was lost in the teaching and theology of the Mass was recovered really only in the 20th century, and that culminated in Sacrosanctum Concilium and the post-conciliar reforms. And while the pendulum has swung too far in the other direction at times, there is much goodness and value in the post-conciliar reforms.

    I say all of this to take nothing away from the general thrust of your post, which I mostly agree with, but I wanted to add a few points that I felt needed clarification.

    In Christ.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s